Rings Of Power Ep 5 Debunks 1 Adar/Sauron Theory (And Sets Up A Bigger One)

This article contains spoilers for The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power episode 5.The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Episode 5 debunked a major theory about the mysterious villain Adar, but set up an even bigger one. Set during the Second Age of Middle-earth, long before the events of The Lord of the RingsHowever, Amazon’s latest fantasy TV series surprised viewers by introducing a number of characters that don’t seem to have any basis in Tolkien’s mythology. One of them, Adar, even seems to be the main antagonist of power rings episode 5.


Adar served the dark being Morgoth during the wars of the First Age, and he appears to be one of Morgoth’s former lieutenants – along with Sauron. Its name comes from an old Elvish word which means “dad,“which possibly implies that he is the one who created the Orcs given that they treat him with an attitude of reverent worship. Adar seems to be carrying out a plan devised centuries earlier in the event of Morgoth’s defeat, who will be followed by his chosen successor. Under the leadership of Adar, an Orcish army takes over the Southlands – the region destined to become the harsh and ominous volcanic wasteland of Mordor. This has naturally led to speculation that he is working for Sauron or that he is actually an alias of Sauron himself.

Related: The Stranger’s Black Arm Makes 2 Rings Of Power Theories More Compelling

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power episode 5 strongly suggested that was not the case, however. In an angry outburst, Adar dismisses any suggestion that he is actually Sauron hiding in plain sight, possibly hinting at a potential rivalry between the character and the legendary Dark Lord. It seems the Amazon series eschews such a simple plot and sets up something much more complex – a story in which evil turns against evil, rather than allying against the forces of light. It’s a smart approach, and it would mean that even now viewers haven’t seen Sauron’s hand yet, debunking the original Adar/Sauron theory in the process.

Rings Of Power Episode 5 Strongly Suggests Adar Isn’t Working For Sauron

In The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power episode 5, a group of Sauron loyalists approach the Orcs and offer to join Adar’s forces. One of them, Waldreg, foolishly calls Adar Sauron; the fallen elf angrily denies this and actually seems outraged by the comparison. Given that Adar is the one carrying out the ancient plan reserved for Morgoth’s successor, it’s highly likely that he was the one who claimed this mantle – not Sauron. While it is true that Sauron often worked through intermediaries in Tolkien The Lord of the RingsAdar appears to be a major, independent antagonist in his own right.

A Fallen Elf is, of course, a force to be reckoned with in the first place. Although JRR Tolkien toyed with the idea of ​​Orcs being created from fallen Elves when creating Middle-earth, he walked away from the idea; Tolkien preferred to believe that his fantasy races had innate qualities, and so he emphasized the inherent nobility of the Elves. Adar doesn’t quite break the Lord of the Rings canon, but it’s probably as close to the idea as the Amazon TV show gets. Adar is presumably at least as old as Galadriel, with his own bitter history explaining the scars that line his face and body, and if he is indeed the creator of the Orcs, he will surely prove a worthy successor to Morgoth.

Rings Of Power Teases Sauron Betrayed Morgoth, Sets Up Adar Fight

Most viewers shared Galadriel’s view that Sauron is the real culprit behind the rising darkness in Middle-earth. This assumption is natural, given that Sauron is the great villain of The Lord of the Rings; he is also responsible for creating the One Ring, and the Amazon series is an exploration of the ring’s origin. Still, if Sauron isn’t Morgoth’s successor, it’s possible he’s working for his own ends in the growing darkness instead.

Related: Gandalf Could Be Rings Of Power’s Meteor Man (And Not Break The LOTR Cannon)

It would be a smart approach to The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, reinforcing the sense that Sauron’s evil does not come from overwhelming force but rather from his Machiavellian scheming. The strength of Adar’s reaction suggests that he is now seen as a traitor to Morgoth and his successor, someone who acts independently and will take advantage of the chaos caused by Adar to get what he wants. It even raises the possibility that Sauron was part of the series from the start, given that Tolkien envisioned him as a master of disguise. Rather than acting in secret, he could do so in broad daylight, preparing for the inevitable moment when he will come face to face with his rival Adar and prove that he is the greater of the two.

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power releases new episodes at 9 p.m. PT Thursdays and 12 p.m. EST Fridays on Prime Video. Want more power rings articles? Check out our essential content below…

Join Amazon Prime – Watch Thousands of Movies and TV Shows Anytime

Start free trial now

Sharon D. Cole