Dark Wizarding World Theory Says Dumbledore Is Harry Potter’s True Enemy

A particularly dark theory about the Harry Potter The franchise suggests that Dumbledore may have manipulated events to ensure the loyalty of the titular boy wizard, and it paints the Headmaster of Hogwarts as a secret villain. The Harry Potter The franchise is known for the depth of its storytelling and the intricate layers of many of its characters, and that’s something that’s been a big part of its success. The Wizarding World’s large cast of colorful characters and each individual’s respective role in the eight-film saga has seen many theories arise regarding various characters, but perhaps none more so than Albus Dumbledore.


The character of Hogwarts’ most famous headmaster is shrouded in mystery and fantasy. Dumbledore’s role as a mentor to Harry throughout his time at Hogwarts means he shaped the entire franchise narrative, making Albus Dumbledore incredibly important to the Harry Potter movies. In keeping with his importance, there has been much speculation about Dumbledore’s true motives and the subtext behind his actions, making him one of the most intriguing supporting characters in the entire franchise.

Related: Dumbledore’s Real Worst Decision Correcting His Biggest Harry Potter Crime

One such theory (shared via Reddit) suggests that Dumbledore may have been secretly much more manipulative than he appears. The theory goes that Dumbledore “collects” outcasts (much like Slughorn “collects” those with potential) and does so as a means of securing the loyalty of his followers. The theory highlights the characteristics of several members of the Order of the Phoenix, as well as some Hogwarts staff, and it even matches Dumbledore’s actions within. Harry Potterthe story. The theorist posits that Dumbledore also deliberately turned Harry himself into an outcast in order to manipulate the course of the boy’s life. Although grim, the theory is surprisingly compelling.

Dumbledore’s most loyal followers are all outcasts

Many members of the Order of the Phoenix, as well as Hogwarts staff, serve as evidence for the theory that Dumbledore was actively seeking outcasts to join him. Some of the most obvious examples would be Remus Lupin, who grew up an outsider due to his lycanthropism, Severus Snape, whose fascination with dark magic was offset by his love for Lily Potter and his own Muggle blood, and Rubeus Hagrid, whose status as a half-giant expelled from Hogwarts has made him one of the wizarding world’s greatest outcasts. Other characters that similarly fit the pattern are Dobby the house-elf, Newt Scamander (from fantastic beasts franchise), and Harry Potter himself.

Why Dumbledore chose such people to be by his side may be innocent, but the theory suggests he may have had an ulterior motive. It is possible that Dumbledore is responsible for these Harry Potter the characters all being involved in his own plans for the wizarding world, as he recognized that their need to belong would prove an easy method of securing their loyalty to him. By giving outsiders a place where they could feel accepted and valued, Dumbledore engendered loyalty within his own ranks in a way Voldemort never did.

How Dumbledore’s Less Reliable Knowledge Fits Theory

According to the theory, even those who don’t quite fit the pattern prove Dumbledore’s tactic. Other characters who are less adamant in their support of Dumbledore aren’t pariahs of the same ilk, and this subtle quirk of characterization seems to affect their relationship with Dumbledore. Harry’s godfather, Sirius Black, for example, was a bit of an outsider, but not an outright outcast – he was more of a rebel, deliberately avoiding his family values ​​and instead joining the Order of the Phoenix to fight back. against Voldemort. Although the two men enjoy mutual respect, Black has never been as close to Dumbledore as Hagrid or Snape, and that’s because his place in Dumbledore’s inner circle was of his own choosing. The theory suggests that Dumbledore relied less on Sirius because, as a rebel, he was something of a dark horse, as opposed to the outcasts Dumbledore had rounded up and conditioned to do his bidding.

Related: Harry Potter Created Dumbledore’s Plot Hole In 2007 (And No One Noticed)

Harry is an outcast because of the Dursleys

One of the key elements of Harry Potter’s story is his escape from the mundane and abusive Muggle world to the magical world of Hogwarts. Growing up with his maternal aunt and uncle after his parents were murdered, Harry was regularly abused. The Dursleys hated Harry for his magical nature – though he was largely unaware of it – and they made his young life as miserable as possible. After finally ending up at Hogwarts, Harry believes he has found his home as it opens the door to a world in which he is famous and revered, which for the young wizard stands in stark contrast to his unpleasant upbringing.

The Dursleys make Harry an outcast in more ways than one. Rather than simply isolate and severely mistreat him, they actively discourage his belief in magic, preventing him from having a connection to the world he belongs to. When Harry reaches Hogwarts, he is somewhat at a disadvantage thanks to the Dursleys and their intolerance. of his magical abilities: he knows nothing of magic, and this further isolates him even after escaping the muggle world. Once Harry Potter is at Hogwarts, he discovers the depth to which he has been alienated from his own past, making him an outsider from the very beginning due to the Dursleys’ actions.

Dumbledore placed Harry with the Dursleys to ensure his loyalty

The final dart of the theory – and the part that really describes Dumbledore as a villain – combines the reasons for Harry’s outcast status with the idea of ​​Dumbledore’s true motivations. The theorist believes Dumbledore deliberately placed Harry with the Dursleys to ensure he grew up in an intolerant and abusive environment, creating the desire to belong that drove Harry to Dumbledore’s side. The theory holds that Harry’s loyalty to Dumbledore is a direct result of the powerful and calculated manipulation of the Hogwarts professor, with everything going as Dumbledore intended.

This is where the theory paints Dumbledore as a villain because it imagines Dumbledore to be as complicit in Harry’s suffering as Voldemort himself. Of course, it was Voldemort who orphaned Harry, but Dumbledore may have facilitated an abuse-filled childhood, arguably causing him as much emotional damage as the infamous dark wizard. If Harry’s abusive childhood was in fact the result of Albus Dumbledore’s machinations designed specifically to ensure the boy grew up feeling like an outsider, then the theory makes Dumbledore one of Harry Potterthe most heartless villains.

Sharon D. Cole